I've been thinking a lot about the film The Searchers recently, perhaps because my Mom and Dad lost a dog named after a character in that film. It's on an informal list I'm keeping of films I need to watch for the 12th or 13th time along with The Godfather, Witness, and High Noon.
There are films, however, that I remember finding great but have no wish to see again. They are:
The Sixth Sense
For different reasons each, these were great films. But for different reasons each, I really cannot pull from them nearly the same experience I got watching them the first time.